Throughout the coronavirus pandemic, millions of Americans have relied on emergency orders put in place by state and local governments that bar utility companies from shutting off services such as gas, electricity and water.
Governors and public utility commissions in 32 states passed new utility shutoff moratoriums during the pandemic, which prohibited providers from shutting off utilities because of nonpayment. Several states, such as Ohio and Arizona, did not pass new orders but extended seasonal shutoff restrictions during the pandemic. Yet overall, many of these measures were put in place as short-term solutions, so most of the moratoriums are set to expire soon. Ten states have already had their orders expire, but the bulk are lifting in August, September and October, Carbon Switch’s report finds.
Meanwhile, 14 states never issued specific moratoriums at all, instead relying on utility companies to voluntarily keep power on for customers with overdue bills. Yet 8 out of 10 of the nation’s biggest utility companies are planning to return to normal operations by Sept. 15 and will start cutting off customers’ electricity and gas if the bills are overdue, Carbon Switch reports.
“There’s going to be a tidal wave of utility shutoffs,” says Michael Thomas, founder and head researcher of Carbon Switch. That’s because in some states, as many as a third of households are behind on payments. Typically, only about 7% to 9% of Americans are delinquent on their payments, he says. “It’s just crazy by any measure.”
Throughout August and September, 14 state moratoriums will expire. Carbon Switch calculates that by October 1, about 76 million households will be without shutoff protections. At that point, only a dozen states and Washington, D.C. will still have moratoriums still in place. Only seven states — California, Connecticut, Kentucky, Maine, Massachusetts, New York and Wyoming — and Washington, D.C. do not have expiration dates set on their moratorium orders, according to Carbon Switch.
About 9.5 million people are currently unemployed in states that are set to have their shutoff protections expire on or before October 1, according to the report’s analysis of the latest monthly data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Another 10 million of the households in those states are currently below the federal poverty line, Carbon Switch finds.
Effects not felt equally
Prior to the pandemic, low-income Americans and Black and Hispanic households were disproportionately affected by utility shutoffs. Black households earning less than 150% times the federal poverty level were twice as likely to have their electricity shut off as white families with comparable income levels, National Consumer Law Center analyst John Howat estimates.
A 2018 California study found that while Latino utility customers make up roughly a third of people living in PG&E’s service territory, 62%, live in ZIP codes with the highest shut off rates.
The pandemic will likely exacerbate these issues, Thomas says. A recent survey by researchers at Indiana University found that Black respondents were twice as likely as White respondents to report they were unable to pay their utility bills in April or May.
Struggling to pay for utilities can have an impact on Americans’ health. Nearly a fourth, 22%, of the Indiana University respondents said they reduced or cut down on food and medicine in order to pay their utility bills.
“Energy insecurity is already a widespread problem in the U.S. It disproportionately affects those at or below the poverty line, Black and Hispanic households, families with young children, people with disabilities and those who use electronic medical devices,” the researchers wrote.
How to get help with utility bills
If you are struggling to pay your energy, water or telephone bills, contact your utility company directly to ask about bill assistance programs. Only 1% of eligible households take advantage of these programs, the NCLC finds.
You may also qualify for assistance through the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), which is a federal program for low-income families that helps with energy bills. While income eligibility requirements vary by state, generally a four-person household earning less than $36,400 qualifies. You can call the National Energy Assistance Referral (NEAR) hotline toll-free at 1-866-674-6327 to get information on where to apply for LIHEAP.
The federally funded program Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) can help with basic assistance as well as expenses related to housing, food, child care and job training. Each state runs its TANF program differently, but you can look up each program by state.
There are also grants, programs and even charities where you may be able to apply for payment assistance. UtilityBillAssistance.com provides a helpful state-by-state breakdown.
If you’re struggling to pay your phone bill, the Federal Communications Commission has a program called Lifeline that provides discounted landline or cell phone service to low-income families.
“There are so many people who have lost parts of their income or all their income,” Thomas says, which makes the number of customers at risk for getting their utilities cut off that much higher right now.
Here’s a look at the status of each state’s shutoff protections.
Status of state utility moratoriums
|New Jersey||Always voluntary|
|North Dakota||Always voluntary|
|South Dakota||Always voluntary|
|New York||Expiration TBD|
|Indiana||Expired on August 14|
|West Virginia||Expired on July 1|
|Georgia||Expired on July 14|
|Louisiana||Expired on July 16|
|Illinois||Expired on July 26|
|Montana||Expired on June 30|
|South Carolina||Expired on May 14|
|Mississippi||Expired on May 26|
|Iowa||Expired on May 27|
|Kansas||Expired on May 31|
|New Mexico||Expires on August 28|
|Tennessee||Expires on August 29|
|Alaska||Expires on November 15|
|Hawaii||Expires on October 1|
|Arizona||Expires on October 15|
|Washington||Expires on October 15|
|New Hampshire||Expires on October 16|
|Arkansas||Expires on October 18|
|Pennsylvania||Expires on September 06|
|Maryland||Expires on September 1|
|North Carolina||Expires on September 1|
|Wisconsin||Expires on September 1|
|Minnesota||Expires on September 11|
|Virginia||Expires on August 31|
|Rhode Island||Expires on September 30|
|Texas||Expires on September 30|
|Vermont||Expires on September 30|
|Delaware||Expires on September 5|
|Colorado||Expires on September 9|